84%Probability that Dems retain controlHouse Race Projectionsdem 193toss up 30gop 212
77%Probability of Gop takeoverGovernor Race Projectionsdem 16toss up 4gop 29
+6Probable gain in Gop governorshipsDean BakerCo-Director of the Center for Economic and Policy ResearchPosted: October 31, 2010 09:59 AMBIOBecome a FanGet Email AlertsBloggers' Index
function hide_user_promo_bubble_second_stage() {var bubble = $("user_promo_bubble");bubble.style.display = "none";}function hide_user_promo_bubble() {var bubble = $("user_promo_bubble");var myAnim = new YAHOO.util.Anim(bubble, {opacity: {to: 0}}, 1, YAHOO.util.Easing.easeOut);myAnim.animate();setTimeout("hide_user_promo_bubble_second_stage()", 1100);}function handle_promo_username(params) {var bubble = $("user_promo_bubble");var img = $("user_promo_bubble_image");var anchor = $("user_promo_bubble_link");if (params.has_photo == "true") {img.src = "http://images.huffingtonpost.com/profiles/" + params.user_id + "-tiny.png";} else {img.style.display = "none";Dom.addClass(anchor, "wide");}anchor.innerHTML = "Shared by " + params.user_name;anchor.href = "http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/" + params.user_name;bubble.style.display = "block";var myAnim = new YAHOO.util.Anim(bubble, {opacity: {to: 1}}, 2, YAHOO.util.Easing.easeOut);myAnim.animate();}if (HuffPoUtil.getUrlVar("user_promo")) {YAHOO.util.Event.onDOMReady(function() {var parts = document.location.hash.split(","), shared_by = "", badge = "", i;if (parts.length David Broder Calls for War With Iran to Boost the Economy What's Your Reaction: HPConfig.entry_digg_promo_url = 'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dean-baker/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587.html';digg facebook Twitter stumble redditdel.ico.us ImportantFunny
Typical
Scary
Outrageous
Amazing
Innovative
Finally
Read More:Federal Budget Deficit, Stimulus, War, Washington Post, Politics News
Get Politics AlertsEmailComments16
This is not a joke (at least not on my part). David Broder, the longtime columnist and reporter at a formerly respectable newspaper, quite explicitly suggested that fighting a war with Iran could be an effective way to boost the economy. Ignoring the idea that anyone should undertake war as an economic policy, Broder's economics is also a visit to loon tune land.
Broder tells readers:
"Can Obama harness the forces that might spur new growth? This is the key question for the next two years.
What are those forces? Essentially, there are two. One is the power of the business cycle, the tidal force that throughout history has dictated when the economy expands and when it contracts.
Economists struggle to analyze this, but they almost inevitably conclude that it cannot be rushed and almost resists political command. As the saying goes, the market will go where it is going to go.
In this regard, Obama has no advantage over any other pol. Even in analyzing the tidal force correctly, he cannot control it.
What else might affect the economy? The answer is obvious, but its implications are frightening. War and peace influence the economy."
Sorry Mr. Broder, outside of Fox on 15th the world does not work this way. War affects the economy the same way that other government spending affects the economy. It does not have some mystical impact as Broder seems to think.
If spending on war can provide jobs and lift the economy then so can spending on roads, weatherizing homes, or educating our kids. Yes, that's right, all the forms of stimulus spending that Broder derided so much because they add to the deficit will increase GDP and generate jobs just like the war that Broder is advocating (which will also add to the deficit).
So, we have two routes to prosperity. We can either build up our physical infrastructure and improve the skills and education of our workers or we can go kill Iranians. Broder has made it clear where he stands.
Wash Post More in Politics...
Rally To Restore Sanity Attendance Estimated In...
Christine O'Donnell Reveals Surprising Personal Info (VIDEO)
Voter Intimidation At McDonald's: Employees Told That,...
Lauren Valle, Head-Stomped MoveOn Activist, Responds To... function returnCommentDetails(params) {// this is the proxy method. just proxyreturn CommentsSharer.getHoveredCommentDetails(params);};function callback_for_loaded_Badges(params) {//console.log("callback_for_loaded_Badges() called");CommentsSharer.badge_object = params.badge_object; // not actualy used, by could be usefulCommentsSharer.badge_holder_id = params.badge_holder_id; // not actualy used, by could be useful}diggstumbleredditdel.ico.usCommentsSharer.initBadgeBox("comment_share_popup"); Comments 16 Pending Comments 2 View FAQ
Login or connect with: More Login OptionsLogin with: Google Account Huffpost Account Yahoo AccountYou must be logged in to comment.Post CommentPreview CommentTo reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.Share your Comment:
Post to Facebook.Post to Blogger.Post to Twitter.Post to WordPress.Post to TypePad.Post to Tumblr.Post to Yahoo! View All Favorites Recency | Popularity justan olnamvet 5 minutes ago (11:45 AM) 23 Fans Mr. Broder s/b outfitted in military gear and sent to Iran in exchange for the two hikers still held there. justan_olnamvet: Mr. Broder s/b outfitted in military gear and sent to http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/justan_olnamvet/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65670504.html Permalink | Share it
Quinterius 8 minutes ago (11:42 AM) 30 Fans David Broder used to be a reasonable and somewhat liberal political commentator. He has now descended to the lowest form of neo-con media pundit. His statement, "Iran is the greatest threat to the world in the young century," is totally without merit. Iran is not a threat to anybody, including Isra*el. He also claims that we should stop "Iran's ambition to become a nuclear power." What he neglects to say is that Iran's ambition is not to build nuclear bombs. It is to master the technology of nuclear science with applications in energy production, nuclear medicine and related peaceful areas. Quinterius: David Broder used to be a reasonable and somewhat liberal http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Quinterius/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65670171.html Permalink | Share it Au4 21 minutes ago (11:29 AM) 5 Fans what Broder reveals unmistakeably is 1) how out of control "the economy" is, 2)how in thrall to the god of "the economy" we are; and 3) what lengths we will go to to appease the angry god of "the economy"scary stuff Au4: what Broder reveals unmistakeably is 1) how out of control http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Au4/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65668913.html Permalink | Share it
Tom Hickey 22 minutes ago (11:28 AM) 19 Fans David Broder is clearly oblivious of Minsky's work on the financial cycle v. the business cycle. The reason the economic is stuck where it is results from the ending of the long financial cycle that culminates in Ponzi finance. The toxic debt needs to be cleared out before a recovery can take hold in earnest and that has not happened yet, since the financial sector is determined not to write down any of the debt to speak of.Not only is Mr. Broder ill-informed, but also his suggestion that starting a war to improve the economy is so over the top as to require his immediate retirement, giving him the benefit of the doubt that it is only the result of senility rather than socio-pathology. Tom_Hickey: David Broder is clearly oblivious of Minsky's work on the http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Tom_Hickey/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65668821.html Permalink | Share it
James Leo 26 minutes ago (11:24 AM) 146 Fans Good Mr Brooder can volunteer his sons and daughters for the cause. If you think Iraq went well, remember Iran is 3X the size and has a much larger/trained and equipped military. ;OH, the biggest buyer of Iran's oil is China and since they are funding the Chamber of Commerce I don't think their well funded candidates (GOP) are going to go for it. James_Leo: Good Mr Brooder can volunteer his sons and daughters for http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/James_Leo/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65668416.html Permalink | Share it
HUFFPOST SUPER USER Dameocrat 28 minutes ago (11:22 AM) 81 Fans Follow centrism is neoconservatism, and neoliberalism not moderation! Dameocrat: centrism is neoconservatism, and neoliberalism not moderation! http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Dameocrat/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65668253.html Permalink | Share it Poboy 34 minutes ago (11:16 AM) 86 Fans "Economists struggle to analyze this, but they almost inevitably conclude that it cannot be rushed and almost resists political command. As the saying goes, the market will go where it is going to go."Interesting how the market will go where the market will go was not advocated and practiced when the big banks were going down.
Then the government had a command role. Poboy: "Economists struggle to analyze this, but they almost inevitably conclude http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Poboy/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65667663.html Permalink | Share it
ratinacage 38 minutes ago (11:12 AM) 15 Fans Can't fight three wars without more soldiers. Reinstating the draft is just what this country needs to get the young people off of their video games and into the streets. ratinacage: Can't fight three wars without more soldiers. Reinstating the draft http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/ratinacage/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65667264.html Permalink | Share it bathroomonkey7 26 minutes ago (11:24 AM) 61 Fans Follow Makes sense. Get them off their couches and let them be pawns in a military run video game. bathroomonkey7: Makes sense. Get them off their couches and let them http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/bathroomonkey7/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65668464.html Permalink | Share it
MajorKong 46 minutes ago (11:04 AM) 920 Fans "When people speak to you about a preventative war, you tell them to go and fight it." - Dwight D. Eisenhower MajorKong: "When people speak to you about a preventative war, you http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/MajorKong/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65666569.html Permalink | Share it Dan Sacks 53 minutes ago (10:57 AM) 0 Fans Reading the article, I don't see where he ever advocates actually going to war. It appears the author took some liberties with his summary. Dan_Sacks: Reading the article, I don't see where he ever advocates http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Dan_Sacks/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65665964.html Permalink | Share it Poboy 36 minutes ago (11:14 AM) 86 Fans nonsense.
The implications are clear.
Broder is advocating war with Iran as a way to stimulate the economy, appease Republicans and for Obama to be a great President, which is just crazy. Poboy: nonsense. The implications are clear. Broder is advocating war with http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Poboy/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65667465.html Permalink | Share it Buckeye54 1 hour ago (10:42 AM) 123 Fans Ah, these chickenhawks advocating for war—you can't keep them down, can we? And now we're advocating for war for economic reasons?
David Broder has slipped the bounds of sanity and slipped into the Twilight Zone. Buckeye54: Ah, these chickenhawks advocating for warâ??you can't keep them down, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Buckeye54/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65664676.html Permalink | Share it Bellimbusto 1 hour ago (10:41 AM) 49 Fans The war with Iran is inevitable. Neither diplomacy nor sanctions will stop the mullahs in their drive to go nuclear. At the same time, President Obama has said many times, 'We are determined to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons.' The military option is the only avenue left. Bellimbusto: The war with Iran is inevitable. Neither diplomacy nor sanctions http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/Bellimbusto/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65664624.html Permalink | Share it
HUFFPOST SUPER USER ennis438 1 hour ago (10:25 AM) 27 Fans If Dave wants to go to war , then let him go. However, we need to get our troops home NOW. As evidenced by what happened last week, a decade of American troops dying for nothing but lies has not stopped terrorists from acting , and the longer we are occuping their countries, the more these people will react and respond. I don't blame them. If they were occuping my country, I would do the exact same thing. As for Dave, let him go to war as long as he enjoys it. ennis438: If Dave wants to go to war , then let http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/ennis438/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65663292.html Permalink | Share it fpie 2 hours ago (10:11 AM) 29 Fans War does have one advantage over peace based spending: Republicans will always vote for war. War is like cocaine for GOPers. They can't get enough, as long as they or their near and dear don't have to fight. fpie: War does have one advantage over peace based spending: Republicans http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/fpie/david-broder-calls-for-wa_b_776587_65662259.html Permalink | Share it New comments on this entry — Click to refresh
Charlie Sheen Found Nude In Restaurant, Screaming N-Word:...2,663 Comments
'Shape' Editor: LeAnn Rimes Cover Was 'A Terrible Mistake'1,272 Comments
'Teen Mom' Stars' Big Salaries Revealed692 Comments
Michael P. McDonald A Late Democratic Early Voting Surge in...1,135 Comments
Zach Carter Are Treasury's Knives Coming Out Against...667 Comments
7 Rings, Day 7: Rebecca Campbell Bites65 Comments
CBS: Sanity Rally Attendance OBLITERATED Turnout To Glenn Beck Rally7,626 Comments
Politico Has Concerns About Rally To Restore Sanity For Some...2,662 Comments
Obama: More Aggressive Anti-Foreclosure Efforts Would Help Undeserving People8,370 Comments HuffPost ReporterskxSjfEdPWG7K9s1gOL2%2BxMAcpLR6mjZ4bML2kf7VNmcIEwyJCY3XvxvAud7UwJkA1 of 2
Sam Stein: Michael Steele: Even If We Fall Short...45 Comments
Amanda Terkel: Sen. John Cornyn Denies The GOP Is...7 Comments
Sam Stein: Sarah Palin: 'Corrupt Bastards' In Media Tried...182 Comments Don't Miss HuffPost Bloggers1 of 5
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Croobert News\huffingtonpost\time_logo.png)
Halloween Candy: A Numeric Breakdown
Quotes: Texas Rangers Fan on His Team's Chances in the World Series
Reverse Photoshopping: New Photo Meme Fattens Up The Celebs TOP VIDEO PICKS1 of 5
Devices have 'al-Qaeda hallmarks'
Senate show down in Nevada.
Federal Money Sent to the Dead
CBS: Sanity Rally Attendance OBLITERATED Turnout To Glenn Beck Rally7,069 Comments
Sarah Palin Responds To Karl Rove's Latest Swipe: Reagan Was On TV Too (VIDEO)488 Comments
In election's shadow, rally draws laughs, activism21,975 Comments
GOP Plans Attacks On EPA, Climate Scientists187 Comments
Bad News For Sarah Palin's Presidential Hopes1,511 Comments
Poll: Nearly HALF Of Democrats Want Obama To Face Primary Challenge In 20125,882 Comments
Candidates Against Government Spending Who Profit On The Side498 Comments
Sharron Angle Promises 'Shock And Awe'1,911 Comments
Elections 2010 LIVE Updates7,008 Comments
PHOTOS From The Rally To Restore Sanity467 Comments HOT ON FACEBOOKtJA38M%2BO%2BL5IRLnce24bXQ%3D%3DHN2BE5vZxQ5SJNHfeWK0Ng%3D%3DFFFO0FRUzhUb3fd%2B%2BGPyIw%3D%3DrnANGJhsJ1h3FDAkv3kAKw%3D%3DpMMpeebEL8RPgICoQM4KVw%3D%3D1 of 5
SAD MEAL: Voter Intimidation At McDonald's Franchise10,820 Comments
WATCH: Christine O'Donnell Reveals Surprising Personal Info2,183 Comments
PHOTOS From The Rally To Restore Sanity482 Comments
Sarah Palin Responds To Karl Rove's Latest Swipe: Reagan Was On TV Too (VIDEO)693 Comments
Lauren Valle, Head-Stomped MoveOn Activist, Responds To Stomper's Request For Apology3,380 Comments
WATCH: Greek Celebrities Team Up For Get-Out-The-Vote Video195 Comments
Candidates Against Government Spending Who Profit On The Side512 Comments
Bad News For Sarah Palin's Presidential Hopes1,521 Comments
Poll: Nearly HALF Of Democrats Want Obama To Face Primary Challenge In 20125,920 Comments
CBS: Sanity Rally Attendance OBLITERATED Turnout To Glenn Beck Rally7,571 Comments HOT ON TWITTERtJA38M%2BO%2BL5IRLnce24bXQ%3D%3DHN2BE5vZxQ5SJNHfeWK0Ng%3D%3DFFFO0FRUzhUb3fd%2B%2BGPyIw%3D%3DrnANGJhsJ1h3FDAkv3kAKw%3D%3DpMMpeebEL8RPgICoQM4KVw%3D%3D1 of 5
Sarah Palin: 'Corrupt Bastards' In Media Tried To Find Child Molester In Joe Miller Crowd23 Comments
Candidates Against Government Spending Who Profit On The Side498 Comments
WATCH LIVE: Obama Rallies Voters In Chicago855 Comments
GOP Plans Attacks On EPA, Climate Scientists187 Comments
PHOTOS From The Rally To Restore Sanity467 Comments
WATCH: Greek Celebrities Team Up For Get-Out-The-Vote Video190 Comments
Tea Party Candidates Have Drained GOP Resources1,521 Comments
Poll: Nearly HALF Of Democrats Want Obama To Face Primary Challenge In 20125,882 Comments
CBS: Sanity Rally Attendance OBLITERATED Turnout To Glenn Beck Rally7,069 Comments
Sarah Palin Responds To Karl Rove's Latest Swipe: Reagan Was On TV Too (VIDEO)488 Comments HUFFPOST'S BIG NEWS PAGES
Michael Steele: Even If We Fall Short In The House It's A SuccessMichael Steele
Sen. John Cornyn Denies The GOP Is Turning Its Back On Joe Miller, But Won't Say If He Can Win In Alaska (VIDEO)Video
Sarah Palin: 'Corrupt Bastards' In Media Tried To Find Child Molester In Joe Miller CrowdSarah Palin
Free Birth Control: Health Care Overhaul My Provide Pill As Preventative MedicineHealth Care
Ronnie & Clyde: Rihanna & Shy Ronnie Team Up For Another SNL Digital Short (VIDEO)SNL
Aigle Azur, French Airline, Lands First Flight To BaghdadAirlines
Sighosoar, Romania: The Purported Home Of Dracula (PHOTOS)Halloween
TV SoundOff: Sunday Talking HeadsMeet the Press
GOP Plans Attacks On EPA, Climate ScientistsClimate Changemore big news pages » Front PagePoliticsBusinessMediaEntertainmentComedySportsStyleWorldGreenTech Food Travel Living Health Arts Books Religion Impact Education College NY LA Chicago Denver BlogsAdvertise | Make HuffPost your Home Page | RSS | Careers | FAQ | Contact UsCopyright © 2010 HuffingtonPost.com, Inc. | User Agreement | Privacy | Comment Policy | About Us | Powered by Movable Type

No comments:
Post a Comment