Croobert News: Derrick Crowe: General Petraeus, Proconsul of Fantasyland

Derrick Crowe: General Petraeus, Proconsul of Fantasyland HPFB.init();

HuffPost's QuickRead... ShareBox.ad = function (tag_id){if ($(tag_id) == undefined) return; if ($(tag_id).innerHTML != '') return;ad_spec = {"zone_info": "huffpost.world/blog;world=1;nickname=derrick-crowe;entry_id=764972;afghan-ngo-safety-office=1;afghanistan=1;afghanistan-war=1;anso=1;helmand=1;kandahar=1;obama=1;petraeus=1;rethink-afghanistan=1;war-in-afghanistan=1","ord": 1287184609,"tile": 3,"width": 300,"height": 250,"el_id": tag_id + "_js","class_name": "ad_block ad_wide top","type": "iframe"}HuffPoUtil.WEDGJE.write(ad_spec, tag_id);};Loading... BIG NEWS:Iran|North Korea|Afghanistan|India|Congo| Smarter Ideas| More... | LogoutLog In| Sign Up The Huffington Post October 15, 2010 Front PagePoliticsBusinessMediaEntertainmentComedySportsStyle WorldGreenTechFood TravelLiving ArtsBooks ReligionImpactEducation College NY LA Chicago Denver Blogs

Derrick CrowePolitical Director, Brave New Foundation

Posted: October 15, 2010 06:41 PMBIOBecome a FanGet Email AlertsBloggers' Index

The gap between General Petraeus' rhetoric and the reality on the ground in Afghanistan grows every day.

Yesterday, the Afghan NGO Safety Office (ANSO) released its quarterly report (.pdf) on the security situation in Afghanistan, which described the continued growth of the Afghan armed resistance and a deterioration of security in areas where ISAF made major military pushes. Yet, today, General Petraeus crowed in London about "progress" made in Afghanistan. Americans are wise to the game and don't buy this sort of clap-trap anymore: most Americans believe the war in Afghanistan is a "situation like Vietnam (.pdf)." Yet Petraeus spins on, damaging his own credibility and fooling no one.

The ANSO report paints a grim picture of the reality on the ground in Afghanistan:

The [Taliban] counter-offensive is increasingly mature, complex & effective. Country wide attacks have grown by 59% (p.10) while sophisticated recruitment techniques have helped activate networks of fighters in the North where European NATO contributors have failed to provide an adequate deterrent (p.11). Some provinces here are experiencing double the country average growth rate (p.12) and their districts are in danger of slipping beyond any control. Clumsy attempts to stem the developments, through the formation of local militia's and intelligence-poor operations, have served to polarize communities with the IEA capitalizing on the local grievances that result. In the South, despite more robust efforts from the US NATO contingents, counterinsurgency operations in Kandahar and Marjah have similarly failed to degrade the IEA's ability to fight, reduce the number of civilian combat fatalities (p.13) or deliver boxed Government.
By contrast the [Taliban] are showing signs of transition to their own 'hold & build' phase. Already operating advanced administrations in the rural South & East, local 'shadow governance' structures in the North are being buttressed by cadres of loyalists to reinforce the ideological and political cohesion of the movement. Field reports suggest that these efforts are drawing in more conservative recruits from the Uzbek, Turkmen and Tajik communities affording highly valuable opportunities for expansion. Internal factionalism is being addressed with junior opposition partners (domestic and foreign) being slowly subordinated to their command structure, sometimes violently. At the strategic level, leaders are outlining tentative foreign policy, reassuring neighbors of cooperation on narcotics, the environ- ment and commerce, while alluding to 'the upcoming system of the country'. The sum of their activity presents the image of a movement anticipating authority and one which has already obtained a complex momentum that NATO will be incapable of reversing.
...This year has seen nine consecutive months of deterioration, with each month since May breaking a new record, and high levels of attacks extending well in to the traditional downturn season (Aug-Dec).

In other words, the counterinsurgency campaign is failing all over the dang place. ANSO very helpfully updated their chart showing the number of armed-opposition-group-initiated attacks over time, and the picture is worth a thousand words:

ANSO AOG Initiated Attacks, Q3 2010

...The data rises above day-to-day tactical assessments and presents a remarkably consistent five year pattern of intra-annual cycles, summer peaks and winter troughs driven by climatic conditions on the ground, paired with a very steady 45-55% growth in total attacks between years.
Each new year retains approximately 80% of the previous years growth suggesting that once ground, or capability to attack through manpower, technology or technique, is gained it is seldom relinquished. The pattern suggests careful and deliberate building on last years gains, expanding, consolidating and expanding again.

Lest you think the ANSO data is an outlier, remember that military assessments in both December 2009 and late March 2010 both said that the insurgency's organizational capabilities are qualitatively and geographically expanding.

Now, in this context, with a clear and easily available body of data that includes U.S. military reports, no U.S. media outlet should be uncritically passing along any quote from any military official claiming "progress" in Afghanistan. The American adventure in Afghanistan is a 9-year-plus unequivocal failure with the indicating statistics showing a remarkable consistency.

Yet on Friday, October 15, General Petraeus laughably attempted to paint "a picture of Afghanistan in which the Taliban's ability to mount attacks is being reduced..." The ABC News coverage of Petraeus' remarks came under the headline, "General Petraeus Upbeat, Cites Signs of Progress in Afghanistan." The subsequent story is little more than stenography, reporting Petraeus' narrative without including information that would challenge the general's false depiction of the situation on the ground. The story even claims--without substantiation--that the insurgency has been "knocked back." That's laughable, and easily disproved. See above.

Petraeus went on to describe plans to "link the growing Kandahar security bubble with the one in central Helmand." That begs the question: what planet is Petraeus living on?

Marjah is a basketcase--an example of the failure of the McChrystal/Petraeus strategy. Here's a brief description, courtesy of the Associated Press:

Eight months on, the Taliban are still here in force, waging a full-blown guerrilla insurgency that rages daily across a bomb-riddled landscape of agricultural fields and irrigation trenches.
As U.S. involvement in the war enters its 10th year, the failure to pacify this town raises questions about the effectiveness of America's overall strategy. Similarly crucial operations are now under way in neighboring Kandahar province, the Taliban's birthplace.
There are signs the situation in Marjah is beginning to improve, but "it's still a very tough fight," said Capt. Chuck Anklam, whose Marine company has lost three men since arriving in July. "We're in firefights all over, every day."

Also from the ANSO report:

"Data from Marjah, Helmand (below) paints a similar picture with high rates of attacks persisting 30 weeks after OP MOSHTARAK and an average of two residents per week being killed by AOG in acts of intimidation or collaterally in IED strikes. The closed nature of Marjah makes reliable reporting difficult but anecdotal reports suggest the fighting is much more intense than ANSO records show with possibly as many as 70-100 kinetic events per week. Both operational areas shows signs of the 'dynamic occupation' process typical of the region with AOG melting away ahead of IMF operations only to reappear intact in their wake."

Kandahar is similarly a wreck. Security for the civilian population has rapidly deteriorated since the launch of the ISAF military push there, resulting in a doubling of the war-related injury rate for civilians, according to the International Committee of the Red Cross. ANSO's data confirms the dire security situation:

"The daily attack rate [in Kandahar] has grown from 0.1 in Week one to 2.8 per day by Week 35 suggesting that the ele- ments of OP HAMKARI un- dertaken so far are not de- grading the AOG ability to conduct attacks. Field reports suggest that the Taliban retain up to 4,000 fighters inside the city and continue a wide- spread campaign of intimidation, targeted assassination and the widespread deployment of IEDs against Police and Military targets."

If those are security bubbles, the only thing Petraeus is going to succeed in linking is a discreet arc of deteriorating safety for civilians and rising insurgent attacks. Petraeus's slippery aspirational language can't hide the fact that he and his strategy are failing to produce promised results.

There are no "security bubbles" to link.

These aren't signs of progress.

These are signs of failure.

With roughly 60 percent of the American people opposed to the war in Afghanistan, it's clear that Petraeus is no longer fooling anyone. We know failure when we see it, and we see it in the counterinsurgency strategy pushed by Petraeus, McChrystal, and their think-tank allies.

Where Petraeus is succeeding, however, is in demonstrating conclusively just how disconnected the generals are from reality. But as long as President Obama suspends his disbelief and allows their warped version of reality to drive U.S. policy in Afghanistan, we'll continue to waste lives and resources on a failed policy that corrodes the national interests of the United States. The president once declared he was against, "dumb war." It's past time he acted like it and acted aggressively to rein in the Proconsul of Fantasyland.

The Afghanistan War isn't making us safer, and it's not worth the cost. If you're tired of this brutal, futile conflict, join us at http://facebook.com/RethinkAfghanistan.

Follow Derrick Crowe on Twitter:www.twitter.com/derrickcrowe

Barack ObamaAfghanistan More in World...

Afghans Claim Abuse At Secret U.S. Military...

Millions Of Afghans Suffering From Parasitic Skin...

Chile Miners Do Not Disclose Ordeal Details

Chile Miners Now Deal With Fame: TV... function returnCommentDetails(params) {// this is the proxy method. just proxyreturn CommentsSharer.getHoveredCommentDetails(params);};function callback_for_loaded_Badges(params) {//console.log("callback_for_loaded_Badges() called");CommentsSharer.badge_object = params.badge_object; // not actualy used, by could be usefulCommentsSharer.badge_holder_id = params.badge_holder_id; // not actualy used, by could be useful}diggstumbleredditdel.ico.usCommentsSharer.initBadgeBox("comment_share_popup"); Comments 0 Pending Comments 1 View FAQ

Login or connect with: More Login OptionsLogin with: Google Account Huffpost Account Yahoo AccountYou must be logged in to comment.Post CommentPreview CommentTo reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.

Share your Comment:

Post to Facebook.Post to Blogger.Post to Twitter.Post to WordPress.Post to TypePad.Post to Tumblr.Post to Yahoo! View All Recency | Popularity New comments on this entry — Click to refresh

Loading comments… Loading twitter module...

Most Popular on HuffPost1D6W1lj5M6WK9G8HrrNmPpYjwnutIsA46NL64OmpEOjb1lq3M1nnXYWa6ECwo6MFwd4UUa6QM7AOal8lrn%2F%2Bqg%3D%3DCvAnOteXEp223IerqcDhw5BVOrc3vXju10iC2cbJapU6B2b9At1Mehxd811XYmevufj2NYDUK4t5ioYQbg4maQ%3D%3D1 of 2 Joy Whoopi Walk Off

Whoopi, Joy Walk Off 'The View' After Heated Fight With O'Reilly
14,190 Comments Gavin Rossdale Gay Affair

Gavin Rossdale Admits To Gay Fling
1,168 Comments

Helen Thomas Cries, Calls Obama 'Reprehensible'
5,724 Comments Gambling

11 Freedoms That Drunks, Slackers, Prostitutes And Pirates Pioneered
254 Comments

Michael P. McDonald Early Voting Off to a Fast Start in...
2,182 Comments Traffic

'Suburban Nation'
286 Comments Christine Odonnell

WATCH: Christine O'Donnell Stumped, Can't Name A Recent SCOTUS Decision She Disagrees With
15,220 Comments Jennifer Aniston Joan Collins

Jennifer Aniston's Camp Responds To Joan Collins' Insults
1,332 Comments Npr Rallies

NPR Bans Employees From Stewart, Colbert Rallies
8,144 Comments Don't Miss HuffPost Bloggers1 of 5

Bishop Gene Robinson How Religion Is Killing Our Most Vulnerable Youth

Robin Quivers Nutty for Nutrition

Rev. Jesse Jackson GOP Runs on the "Big Lie"

Dan Rather Help Not Wanted?

Bernard-Henri Lévy Sakineh’s Son Arrested: The Great Silence of Conformist Thinkers

Henry Louis Gates, Jr. Faces of America: Mehmet Oz and the Immigrant Story Pedigree

Al Gore Standing Up Against the Oil Lobby, in California and Beyond

Alec Baldwin Waiting for "Superman": A Monumentally Important Film

Melinda Gates Why We Tell Success Stories (VIDEO)

Ted Danson A Pacific Gem, ProtectedHot Trends chile miners chilean miners rescue darlene etienne haiti eric bellucci gotthard base tunnel #ad_most_pop_234x60_req_wrapper {border:1px solid #cccccc;margin-bottom:10px;padding:30px 22px 10px;background-color:#ffffff;background-image:url('/images/slug_most_popular.gif');background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:center 10px}.times_ticker { background-color:#E1E1E1; border:10px solid #E1E1E1; font-family:Arial,"Helvetica Neue",Helvetica,sans-serif; font-weight:bold; margin:10px 0;}.times_ticker_content {padding:0px 10px 0 10px;background-color:#FFFFFF;}.times_ticker_bottom {padding:0px 10px 0 10px;background-color:#FFFFFF;font-family:Arial;font-size:10px;font-weight:bold;fontcolor:#C1C1C1;text-align:right; height:5px; -moz-border-radius: 0px 0px 4px 4px; -webkit-border-radius: 0px 0px 4px 4px; border-radius: 0px 0px 4px 4px;}.times_ticker_header { height:35px; background:#FFFFFF url(/images/module_bg_border.png) repeat scroll 0px 0px; -moz-border-radius: 4px 4px 0px 0px; -webkit-border-radius: 4px 4px 0px 0px; border-radius: 4px 4px 0px 0px;}.times_ticker_header_text {padding-top:10px;text-align:center;}.times_ticket_container{border-color:#CCC;border-width:1px;border-style:solid none none none;}.times_ticker_image { float:left; padding:10px 13px 10px 0px;}.times_ticker_text {padding:10px 10px 10px 0px;border:1px solid red';}.times_ticker_title {font-family:Arial;font-size:15px;font-weight:bold;color:black';}.times_ticker_readmore {font-family:Arial;font-size:12px;font-weight:bold;color:#093b72;}.times_ticker_title{font-weight:bold;color:black;} Time - World