Sasha AbramskyAuthor of "Inside Obama's Brain"Posted: October 14, 2010 02:11 AMBIOBecome a FanGet Email AlertsBloggers' Index
function hide_user_promo_bubble_second_stage() {var bubble = $("user_promo_bubble");bubble.style.display = "none";}function hide_user_promo_bubble() {var bubble = $("user_promo_bubble");var myAnim = new YAHOO.util.Anim(bubble, {opacity: {to: 0}}, 1, YAHOO.util.Easing.easeOut);myAnim.animate();setTimeout("hide_user_promo_bubble_second_stage()", 1100);}function handle_promo_username(params) {var bubble = $("user_promo_bubble");var img = $("user_promo_bubble_image");var anchor = $("user_promo_bubble_link");if (params.has_photo == "true") {img.src = "http://images.huffingtonpost.com/profiles/" + params.user_id + "-tiny.png";} else {img.style.display = "none";Dom.addClass(anchor, "wide");}anchor.innerHTML = "Shared by " + params.user_name;anchor.href = "http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/" + params.user_name;bubble.style.display = "block";var myAnim = new YAHOO.util.Anim(bubble, {opacity: {to: 1}}, 2, YAHOO.util.Easing.easeOut);myAnim.animate();}if (HuffPoUtil.getUrlVar("user_promo")) {YAHOO.util.Event.onDOMReady(function() {var parts = document.location.hash.split(","), shared_by = "", badge = "", i;if (parts.length Time to Be Smart On Crime and Punishment What's Your Reaction: HPConfig.entry_digg_promo_url = 'http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sasha-abramsky/time-to-be-smart-on-crime_b_762197.html';digg facebook Twitter stumble redditdel.ico.us ImportantFunny
Typical
Scary
Outrageous
Amazing
Innovative
Finally
Read More:American Academy Of Arts And Science, Budget Deficits, California Gubernatorial Race, Daedalus, Deinstitutionalization, Fiscal Crisis, Incarceration Rate, Politics, Prisons, Politics News
Get Politics AlertsEmailComments3
Two weeks ago, I attended the first Meg Whitman-Jerry Brown gubernatorial debate in California. One of the things that struck me was the time-warp quality of Whitman's discussion of crime and punishment.
Time and again, she told her audience how she would be "tough on crime," contrasting her ideas with the purportedly "liberal" record of Brown. She talked about Rose Bird - the more-than-liberal state Supreme Court justice appointed by Brown during his earlier gubernatorial incarnation in the 1970s, and subsequently recalled by disgruntled voters at the start of the "tough-on-crime" epoch. On capital punishment, Brown reluctantly conceded that, while he was personally opposed to the death penalty, his job would be to enforce state laws, including signing execution warrants. Whitman, by contrast, showed no such qualms; for her, the major issue regarding the death penalty was that it took too long to execute people these days. Despite Brown's endorsement by many law enforcement organizations, the Democratic candidate, Whitman averred, simply couldn't be trusted to do the right thing when it came to punishing criminals.
On crime-and-punishment, Whitman is hewing to a script written by governors Deukmejian, Wilson, and Davis in the 1980s, 1990s and early 2000s. After all, supporting every "tough-on-crime" policy, no matter how poorly thought through, how ineffective as an anti-crime strategy, or financially extravagant they might be, had helped Wilson, in particular, ride popular anger to power; and had then smoothed the way to his re-election as governor despite the state suffering considerable economic hurt during his first term.
So, in 2010, tough-on-crime, as a policy gimmick ought to work well. But there's a problem with the script these days, and it's this: a continuance of policies that have resulted in a more-than-quadrupling of California's incarcerated population over the past third of a century doesn't work in an austerity-era. Quite simply, it costs too much to implement -- in the region of $50,000 per year per incarcerated Californian. Regardless of who wins the gubernatorial race, one of the elephants in the room that will have to be confronted if the state is going to learn to live within its diminished financial means, is California's sprawling prison system and broken parole process - that serves mainly as a revolving door shunting released inmates straight back to prison. Spending $10 billion or more per year, on maintaining a prison system that so signally fails to rehabilitate inmates increasingly, in the era of the $19 billion budget deficit, seems a case of throwing good money after bad.
And California's problems aren't unique. After decades of punish-first-ask-questions-later practices, the nation as a whole has become the globe's leading producer both of prisons and of prisoners. One in a hundred adults currently live behind bars, and amongst some groups - particularly young, impoverished African American men, the figures are far, far higher. At any moment in time about one third of young, African American male high school drop-outs are in either prison or jail. In fact, argues Brown University social scientist and economist Glenn Loury, in no other realm of American life are racial inequalities so dramatically played out.
Recently, academic researchers brought together by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences published a special issue of the journal Daedalus given over to looking at the impact of mass incarceration strategies on American politics, economics, and community, and exploring ways out of the mass-incarceration maze that the country has gotten itself lost within.
I was brought aboard as a consultant to this project. What rapidly became clear, in reading through the research, was the broad realization, amongst criminologists from across the political spectrum, both that current incarceration trends have become utterly unsustainable; and that evidence-based alternatives to incarceration have been developed in recent years that, with a bit of political good will behind them, could channel large numbers of defendants away from prison and jail and toward drug treatment facilities, community service, and other forms of intervention. What also became clear is that an increasing number of states are far ahead of California when it comes to looking for ways to scale back their prison systems: several states have created sentencing commissions to rein in excessive sentences created in spasms of political posturing over the past few decades. Others, including conservative states such as North Carolina, have begun factoring in the cost of incarceration when working out appropriate sentences for individuals.
As evidence piles up that prisons are extraordinarily expensive and, at the same time, singularly ineffective in rehabilitating inmates; and as the racially divisive impact of incarceration trends becomes ever-harder to ignore, so an opportunity for real, smart, reform, is opening up. But it comes with a risk attached. And the risk is that states which have spent decades creating vast penal systems will suddenly stampede to release inmates simply so as to save money in these cash-strapped times or to mute criticism of the socially divisive impact of high incarceration levels.
In this regards, I was particularly struck by an essay in Daedalus by Robert Weisberg and Joan Petersilia, of the Criminal Justice Center at the Stanford Law School. Beware of Pyrrhic victories, they warned reformers; beware of a rush to early release that ends up doing more harm than good.
As a historical parallel the authors looked at what happened in the 1960s and 1970s when an earlier era of wholesale incarceration - this time of the mentally ill in asylums - was brought to a close. Heralded as "deinstutionalization," as a humane alternative to brutal hospitals, oftentimes the mentally ill were simply released into a void. "The consequences in some places were horrible," the authors write. "In part because the irresistible mantra of treating the mentally ill in 'the community' ignored the problem that there often was no 'community.' In reality, there was inner-city slum public housing which soon became a psychiatric ghetto."
Petersilia and Weisberg fear a similar process could unfold vis-à-vis returned-to-the-community prisoners. They fear a fierce backlash "if advocates focus solely on the goal of reducing mass incarceration without advocating simultaneously for a sufficient infusion of funds to help criminal offenders become law-abiding citizens." They warn of "millions of young men who may be relieved of the immediate burden of formal state custody but will hardly be prepared to enjoy all the potential benefits thereof."
Criminal justice spending can't be insulated from public sector cuts. Nor should it. But, at the same time, it oughtn't to be seen as the magic bullet for rescuing dilapidated state finances. Deinstitutionalization, whether of the mentally ill or of non-violent, often-addicted prisoners, should never be done on the cheap. To work, states have to be willing to do some heavy lifting and create networks of new institutions to help these men and women function on the outside. In the long run they will cost considerably less to maintain than do prisons, but, unavoidably, in the immediate future states will have to incur considerable start-up costs. It is, however, as the Daedalus essayists show, a price worth paying.
Follow Sasha Abramsky on Twitter:www.twitter.com/breadlineusa
An associate of Jerry Brown calls Meg Wh...
Take Action :: Gavin Newsom :: For a Bet...
CNN.com - Breaking News, U.S., World, We...
Breitbart.tv » Jerry Brown: ‘I Have ...
Atty. Gen. Jerry Brown urges judge to al...
CBS Buries Jerry Brown Campaign’s ‘W...
Riehl World View: Update - Audio Up, Cau...
Report: Recording Captures Brown Camp Ca...
YouTube- JB401.mov
Brown Campaign Responds to Whitman Attac...
Schwarzenegger, Brown File Motions To Re...
Michelle Malkin » Jerry Brown Associat...
Big Government » Blog Archive &...
Election 2010: Jerry Brown apologizes fo...
Meg Whitman's meltdown - Joan Walsh - Sa...
More in Politics...
Nikki Haley Affair Accusations Resurface: Blogger Details...
Obama And Palin RELATED? Website Claims President...
Delaware Senate Debate: Christine O'Donnell Refuses To...
Secret Donations Could Haunt 2012 function returnCommentDetails(params) {// this is the proxy method. just proxyreturn CommentsSharer.getHoveredCommentDetails(params);};function callback_for_loaded_Badges(params) {//console.log("callback_for_loaded_Badges() called");CommentsSharer.badge_object = params.badge_object; // not actualy used, by could be usefulCommentsSharer.badge_holder_id = params.badge_holder_id; // not actualy used, by could be useful}diggstumbleredditdel.ico.usCommentsSharer.initBadgeBox("comment_share_popup"); Comments 3 Pending Comments 0 View FAQ
Login or connect with: More Login OptionsLogin with: Google Account Huffpost Account Yahoo AccountYou must be logged in to comment.Post CommentPreview CommentTo reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.Share your Comment:
Post to Facebook.Post to Blogger.Post to Twitter.Post to WordPress.Post to TypePad.Post to Tumblr.Post to Yahoo! View All Recency | Popularity
OgreDaddy 2 minutes ago (7:12 AM) 246 Fans A few weeks ago, I mentioned that the judge and jury should be required by lawto not only review the case but to also OPENLY consider the cost to taxpayers
of any sentence they hand down.
At $50,000.00 average to incarcerate per year, many sentences are grossly out of scale
with the so called severity of the accused crime.
This especially holds true for non-violent offenders and non-violent marijuana
cases. OgreDaddy: A few weeks ago, I mentioned that the judge and http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/OgreDaddy/time-to-be-smart-on-crime_b_762197_63656564.html Permalink | Share it richmck 2 hours ago (5:41 AM) 0 Fans Maybe anyone who wants to fix the prison system should start by actually looking at a few prison system facts! For instance, according to the State budget, a correctional contract bed saves $22,496 annually and avoids spending $300,000 for construction. Taxpayers might be surprised (or perhaps not) to learn that California has only 4,500 contract beds compared to over 20,000 in Texas and 33,000 in the Federal prison system. If California had 33,000 contract beds, over $640 million would be saved annually in prison operating costs. $8.5 billion in prison construction costs would be avoided. Contract beds should house “Wobblers” (inmates who can serve their brief terms in jail or prison) and parole violators who now occupy over 48,000 expensive prison beds. I wonder if taxpayers would rather cut essential services rather than increase the number of contract beds. Someone should ask them. richmck: Maybe anyone who wants to fix the prison system should http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/richmck/time-to-be-smart-on-crime_b_762197_63654462.html Permalink | Share it
ECT 4 hours ago (3:31 AM) 80 Fans Follow I wonder what Meg Whitman would say or do if one of her close relatives was accised of a crime...and sentenced to be put to death?Meg appears to be a parrot...sorry parrots...but Meg constantly repeats all Tea Baggers on these issues. ECT: I wonder what Meg Whitman would say or do if http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/ECT/time-to-be-smart-on-crime_b_762197_63651953.html Permalink | Share it New comments on this entry — Click to refresh
Chile Miners Rescue: LIVE Updates (VIDEO)10,463 Comments
PHOTOS: Minka Kelly Strips241 Comments
Helen Thomas Cries, Calls Obama 'Reprehensible'4,044 Comments
John Hamilton "Progressive Hunter" Jailhouse Confession:...4,175 Comments
11 Freedoms That Drunks, Slackers, Prostitutes And Pirates Pioneered 209 Comments
Steve Lombardo 21 Days to Go and Democrats Facing a 60 - 70...460 Comments
Courteney Cox & David Arquette SPLIT: Couple Separated Months Ago: Report669 Comments
NPR Bans Employees From Stewart, Colbert Rallies7,152 Comments
LISTEN: Ken Buck Explained To Alleged Rape Victim Why He Wouldn't Take Her Case4,777 Comments HuffPost ReportersSAQVCIhwoHmuTsHu3hFJTFUNrdEpPUL1lSHsaT%2FrHpuUBa2xEB%2BF0NKIGIMBGoun1 of 2
Sam Stein: DNC Launches Ad Campaign On MTV, BET0 Comments
Amanda Terkel: Delaware Senate Debate: Christine O'Donnell Refuses To...1,835 Comments
Amanda Terkel: Christine O'Donnell Stumped When Asked To Name...8,040 Comments Don't Miss HuffPost Bloggers1 of 5
\ABS\Auto Blog Samurai\data\Croobert News\huffingtonpost\time_logo.png)
Hey, NASA: We Need a New Planet
Worker Swept a Mile Through Sewer Pipe is Rescued
Quotes: Jesse Ventura on Sarah Palin TOP VIDEO PICKS1 of 5
Heated Midterm Debates
Joe Manchin under Fire for Campaign Ad
"Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Ban Ends
Keira Knightley Dons Two Looks In One Night (PHOTOS, POLL)Celebrity Style
Condoleezza Rice Charms Jon Stewart, Discusses 'Extraordinary, Ordinary People' (VIDEO)Daily Show
Pakistan Assassination Plot: Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani, Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi Among TargetsPakistan
AOL's Yahoo Bid: AOL, Firms Explore An OfferMicrosoft
An Angry Rabbi Breaks With PaladinoGay Rights
Military Personnel In Debt: SurveyMilitary
Delaware Senate Debate: Christine O'Donnell Refuses To Say Whether Evolution Is A 'Myth,' Calls Opponent 'Marxist' (VIDEO)2010 Elections
Christine O'Donnell Stumped When Asked To Name A Recent Supreme Court Decision She Disagrees With (VIDEO)Supreme Court
John Boehner Has Voted With Nancy Pelosi More Than 50 Percent Of The TimeNancy Pelosimore big news pages » Front PagePoliticsBusinessMediaEntertainmentComedySportsStyleWorldGreenTechFood Travel Living Arts Books Religion Impact Education College NY LA Chicago Denver BlogsAdvertise | Make HuffPost your Home Page | RSS | Careers | FAQ | Contact UsCopyright © 2010 HuffingtonPost.com, Inc. | User Agreement | Privacy | Comment Policy | About Us | Powered by Movable Type

No comments:
Post a Comment